I love a good mystery. I’m a romance writer, but I think a tinge of intrigue added to a book goes a long way.

In my first book, there’s a stalker. Who done it?
In my second, there’s a mystery guy. Who is he?
In my third, there’s a misunderstanding. Will they figure it out?

Conflict doesn’t have to be a mystery, but I think all good authors keep a few cards back to surprise the reader in the end.

But is it okay to leave a mystery unsolved?

Take this one for example.

One day I got home from work and noticed a Wal-Mart bag in the back seat. I didn’t think anything of it, and left it there. A few days later, I opened it. In there was a pair of sweatpants, a pair of jeans, and t-shirt. They were all sizes smaller than my own, and all unfamiliar.

I assumed my sister had left it in there at some point, but sometime later, when I thought to show them to her, she said no, they weren’t hers.

I pondered this for a long time. How did a strange bag of clothing get put into my car? I usually lock the doors. I don’t THINK my husband was cheating on me… in fact I know he wasn’t. *grin* We were with each other almost every moment we weren’t at work, and he really didn’t have the time to. LOL. Plus, if he was, he was pretty dumb to leave the woman’s clothes in my car.

To this day, I have NO idea how that sack got into my car.

It bothered me for a while. A dumb thing, I know, but my writer’s mind went bananas. What if someone had killed somebody, and these were the clothes they’d been wearing? What if they’d washed the blood off but tried to hide them in case there were still traces? What if a spy had changed clothes and stashed their old clothes in my car?

Or… someone could have just mistaken my car for theirs and accidently put them in there. But that isn’t NEARLY as fun of a thought.

The point is, I still think about it from time to time, and it’s still a mystery. I’m unsatisified.

Which is exactly what, in my humble opinion, we do NOT want our readers to be when they finish our book. Yes, they might continue to think about the book, but probably in a frustrated sense verses content or satisfaction. You lose a degree of trust that the reader has giving you to give them a proper conclusion to the story.

Discussion: Do you have any “unsolved” mysteries in your life that you still wonder about? What are your thoughts on ending a book? Do you like to leave a reader hanging for the next one, or leave a “what if” question? And as a reader, what are your thoughts on the matter? This is all friendly discussion of course, feel free to disagree with me! I value everyone’s opinions!!



  1. That is so weird! I would have to go into detective mode too, and try to figure out how the bag of clothes got there!

    I like the idea of having a thread of unsolved mystery or suspense or something throughout our books. But unless we’re planning to write a sequel, I think we need to somehow bring the matter to a satisfying close. Of course that’s my personal preference. I like HEA’s. But I also think it takes skill to be able to wrap up the tension/mystery in a believable way. If we don’t wrap it up, then maybe it will throw our skill into doubt.

  2. Just a simple one today: Where do those socks go in the dryer?
    ~ Wendy

  3. I think the end of my book leave a little bit of wanting, but at the same time, I think it could end the book as well. I depends on how you look at it.

    I can’t think of a life mystery because I am too anal and have to find out the answers to EVERYTHING. I suppose it kinda makes my life slightly boring…

  4. Jody, I totally agree! Mysteries should be solved:-)

    Wendy, Ahhhh, the age old question. Tis the reason I have a basket FULL of unmatched socks. Stupid sock stealers!

    Marybeth, LOL. You are not boring, you are probably a very secure, satisfied person!!

    Nother question to ponder: What about hooks? You know, when the book is wrapped up well, but then you have an epilogue or a sample chapter of the next book in the chapter, and they end with this mind boggling hook that you can’t stand because you just HAVE to know what is going on. Are you all Kosher with that, or does it make you mad at the author for doing such a mean thing?

Comments are closed.